Mr Kiss Kiss Bang Bang: troubling masculinity with James Bond

Jono Baggaley
Dr Ian Kinane
Dr Elly Hanson
Dr Kathy Weston
Jono Baggaley, Dr Ian Kinane, Dr Elly Hanson, Dr Kathy Weston
Could James Bond be a useful source of teaching about sex, relationships, gender norms and misogyny? This episode of Tomorrow is the Question explores Bond as symbol, a loaded figure of sex and violence and potent store of teaching material.…

Mr Kiss Kiss Bang Bang:  troubling masculinity with James Bond

Could James Bond be a useful source of teaching about sex, relationships, gender norms and misogyny? In this episode of Tomorrow is the Question, Jono Baggaley chats to Dr Ian Kinane, Editor of the International Journal of James Bond Studies, Dr Kathy Weston, founder of Tooled Up Education and Fully Human's Dr Elly Hanson to explore Bond as a problematic symbol, a loaded figure of sex and violence and a potent store of teaching material for teenagers.

In this episode, we uncover a surprisingly rich seam of material for exploring sex, relationships, misogyny, gender norms and more with young people. We could call it teaching by bad example and because of this I started a little sceptical — but this conversation won me over.

James Bond has been described as 'an icon of adventure, a guru of male style and an emblem of glamour’ but he is also ‘a champion of consumerism’ and a ‘loaded figure of sex and violence’. He is a character almost all of us will have encountered in some form; his films are amongst the few laden with sex and violence that families sit down together to watch at Christmas. Everyone from teenagers to grandparents will have an opinion on James Bond — and that's what makes him so unique in British popular culture and useful for teaching.  

Fully Human's Dr Elly Hanson has been working with Dr Ian Kinane, Bond expert and Editor of the International Journal of James Bond Studies, and Dr Kathy Weston, founder of Tooled Up Education, to develop some educational resources which use Bond as source material. We got together to discuss the work.

It's a thought provoking conversation in which we explore Bond as symbol of masculinity and Britishness, his problematic approach to sex and relationships and how on earth he manages to fight bad guys with a blood alcohol level which would kill a man twice his size. Finally, of course, we answer the only question which really matters – who is the next Bond? Tune in to find out.

Listen on Spotify, Apple or wherever you get your podcasts.

TRANSCRIPT

Jono Baggaley (JB): Hello and welcome to Tomorrow is the Question, the podcast where we explore what we need to do today for a fully human tomorrow. I'm Jono Baggaley, editor of Fully Human, and in this episode, we're going to be introducing an unexpected source of rich material for exploring sex, relationships, misogyny, gender norms, and more with children and young people. We could call it teaching by bad example. And in fact, when I first discussed using this material with Dr. Elly Hanson, I was a little skeptical.

But by the end of the conversation you're about to hear, I was completely won over. We're talking about a figure from 20th century fiction and film who's been described as an icon of adventure, a guru of male style and an emblem of glamour, but is also a champion of consumerism and a loaded figure of sex and violence. He's a character almost everyone will have encountered in some form, as his films are amongst the few laden with sex and violence that families might sit down together to watch at Christmas.

And it is this fact, that everyone from teenagers to grandparents will have a view, that makes this figure so useful and unique in British popular culture. Of course, I'm talking about James Bond. And who better to discuss this with than Dr Ian Kinnane, editor of the International Journal of James Bond Studies and Bond Expert, alongside Dr Cathy Weston, founder of Tooled Up Education, who's been using Bond to stimulate conversations with families around the dinner table. And Fully Human's Dr Elly Hanson, who is working with Ian and Kathy to develop educational resources using Bond as source material.

I found it a really thought-provoking conversation in which we discuss Bond as symbol of masculinity and Britishness, his problematic approach to sex and relationships, and how on earth he manages to fight bad guys with a blood alcohol level which would kill a man twice his size. Finally, of course, we answer the only question which really matters. Who is the next Bond? Stay tuned to find out.

Welcome to this Fully Human conversation. I am delighted to be joined by Dr. Kathy Weston, who is a criminologist and the founder of Tooled Up Education. Welcome, Kathy.

Dr. Kathy Weston (KW): Thank you.

JB: And Dr. Ian Kinane, who is an associate professor at Roehampton University and also the editor of the International Journal of James Bond Studies. Delighted to have you here, Ian.

Dr Ian Kinane (IK): Hi, Jono. Thanks for having us.

JB: And finally, last but not least, Dr. Elly Hanson, Fully Human's own research lead. Welcome back Elly.

Dr. Elly Hanson (EH): Great to be here.

JB: So we are here to talk about James Bond. Now, in the last episode of Tomorrow is the Question, we did a deep dive exploration into online misogyny. And so in many senses, we can pick up on some of those conversations, because James Bond is arguably, to some extent, an archetypal figure in presentations of misogyny throughout the 20th century and the early 21st, but also a figure through whom we can explore gender norms, relationships, digital literacy and much more beyond. So I'm really excited to be kicking off this conversation.

So I'm going to start with you, Ian, just to really get a sense of who are we talking about when we're talking about James Bond, or perhaps what are we talking about?

IK: Yeah, absolutely. I'm going to start where I tend to like starting with this kind of question. Bond is an orphan. Bond is sent to private school at the behest of his carer and I don't think that's inextricable to who he becomes, let's say, or his function politically, certainly in Britain and in world politics.

He was created by Ian Fleming, himself privately educated (went to Eton College). There's a tendency it seems to read Bond as Fleming, Fleming as Bond, or to sort of see them as the same person. That's not necessarily the case. And we don't ever do that with other authors, but certainly Fleming had something of a kind of reputation that we might recognise from Bond on screen. There's a sense here of his being a kind of blunt instrument, an object, a tool that is weaponised largely against wider world politics. This is a kind of lapdog of British interests who is often sent out to foreign climes to in effect control the world or to bring it under the control, let's say, of, you know, at the time that Fleming was writing in the early 1950s through to the early 1960s, a kind of waning British power.

So this is a symbol, a figurehead of a certain kind of Britishness. And again, I think this is something we can probably delve into a bit more as we talk about the changing notion of what Britishness is. Bond himself we might think of as a kind of an icon of national masculinity. What I mean by that is, you know, we've had at this stage six different actors, not all of whom, I should say are in fact British. The majority of them are not in fact British — so the notion of the of the British national body is called into question, even in the casting and the films. But this sense of him being or representing a kind of homogenised vision of what British masculinity is or should look like.

Now, even if we think of the different actors who've played him over the years, starting famously with Sean Connery, then onto George Lazenby for his one film. Back to Connery for one film, Roger Moore did seven, Timothy Dalton did two, Pierce Brosnan did four, and Daniel Craig did five. Even just, you know, those names connote a certain kind of physicality. We can get a sense of what that body looks like and how it changes from the early 1960s when we started with Connery to the sort of buff, rough and tumble of Daniel Craig. That's a body that's worked out.

So when we talk about Bond as a kind of a representative of a certain type of (what Thomas Hughes might have called) muscular Christianity — the idea of playing out a certain moral, spiritual cleanliness; the idea being that, okay, Bond's body is the perfected ideal, not just of British mores, British morals, but also the kind of ethical, moral, political superiority; Bond's body is greater often than the villain's bodies, which are often scarred or in some ways deformed — there's a sense of him being wrapped up in a kind of national politic as well.

A lot of people will probably recognise the heyday of sort of British culture. 2012, the Olympics, the Queen's Jubilee, Daniel Craig... well, not actually Daniel Craig, but a stunt double for Daniel Craig... jumping out of a helicopter over the Olympics ceremony with... again, the Queen's stunt double... So this alignment in our culture of Bond, Britishness, a certain kind of conservative lapdog, a certain kind of conservative politics, what is Britishness? And again, I imagine this is something we can probably talk a bit more about going forward.

JB: So not only representing masculinity, but a very specific way in which masculinity then represents something to do with the nation.

IK: Absolutely. There's a certain sort of tie between bond as a sort of entity and Britain as a larger political entity, and I don't think it's a coincidence that the time at which Fleming is writing we have Anthony Eden the former Prime Minister... the sort of shame of the Suez Canal crisis... and the sort, of I suppose, deformation of British Empire. From the post-war period onwards you have the concomitant rise of Bond as a sort of icon that steps in or is in some ways replacing a Britain that was seen to be waning in its global power.

So I think there's absolutely an overlap between what we see as the real world decline of British values, Britain in the post-war period, and the sort of projection onto a British identity of all the things that Bond means, both in this country, in Britain, and globally as well.

JB: That's so interesting. I mean, it also represents that shift from the hard power of imperialism into sort of soft power and kind cultural projection. But as I'm sure we'll explore further, ultimately that being a projection that which is fundamentally quite problematic. I think just on this... Elly... we heard a bit from Ian about Bond's roots, if we take him as a sort of human figure. What does that mean for the type of figure that he becomes... the type of man he becomes and represents?

EH: Well, I think in many ways, Bond is actually a very accurate portrayal of a certain trajectory on from what we might call toxic vulnerability. What I mean by that is, you know, experiences of vulnerability as a child where you weren't met with care that were overwhelming. And one path on from those is to develop a bit of a shell, a hard exterior, and to avoid experiences of vulnerability in one's adult life. You know, Bond is an orphan. Bond went to boarding school at a young age. Again, we see some mirror of some of these things in Fleming's own life. And, you know, British culture, particularly at that kind of elite level, in inverted commas, was encouraging a way of dealing with vulnerability, which is to have a stiff upper lip and therefore don't become vulnerable.

And what's really interesting is that Bond is then kind of characterized within the novels and films as a real man. And this is a theme that no doubt Ian can talk more about. And I think what's really interesting to look at is, okay, so, you know, what can this real man do? What are his strengths? What are his capabilities? But also if he has taken that trajectory on from these early life experiences of toxic vulnerability, what can't he do? What does that mean for the parts of himself that he's had to kind of split off from? And this kind of version of masculinity that he's embodying, is that actually more of a straight jacket, a set of constraints of a way that he has to be?

...What do I mean by all of that? Well, James Bond is somebody who, yes, has the power to be physically strong, but does he have emotional strength? If we define strength as the ability to do something difficult or to resist force, does he have the strength to share his vulnerability with a loved one? Does he have the strength to empathise with somebody else? Does he have the strength to share sadness or sorrow? And I think, this is a very different way of looking at Bond, which I think is really powerful to do with young people. And we can get into some of the kind of outcomes of doing that.

JB: Before we come to think about how we might use this with young people and hear from you, Kathy, in terms of some of ways you've been doing that... just thinking about bond right now, Ian. If... you know... because one of the things that the franchise has done successfully is sort of, to some extent, reboot... but at the same time there are still the same bond at its kernel. Where do you think [Bond] is now in relation to society as we are in 2024?

IK: I think the question of what does it mean to be British? What is Britishness? Has been so contentious and has been so brought into the public discourse with things like Brexit, with certain immigration policies. And I think it's found form in the questions around Bond's identity. Can Bond be played by an actor of colour, let's say? Can Bond be played by a woman, let's say? And I think the degree to which people uphold the Bond mythos, the degree to which they gatekeep, to a certain degree, who is allowed to play that character... It's not too far of a stretch, I think, to see this as something of a sort of synonym of who's allowed to say who's British or what constitutes Britishness. And this is a question that has been really at the forefront, I think, of our cultural imagination. I'm thinking as well, particularly of of the hostile policies of recent recent governments and the degree to which people who have lived in this country for most of their lives were — in the Windrush scandal, for instance — sent back, to places like Jamaica, where Fleming wrote his novels.

I'm not as sure the contemporary films are necessarily as progressive as they might like to think they are. So we had in the most recent film, No Time to Die, a black, female 007, which at the time a certain section of people were up in arms saying this is quote unquote too woke. A term I'm not going to mention again, but just to sort of say the degree to which the filmmakers let's say might have been able to have their cake and eat it... So Daniel Craig gets to play James Bond, but Lashana Lynch gets to play 007. I think it's quite an effective way to show actually Bond, and who we think of as the icon 007 are in fact extricable in the canon universe of this film.

But I think as well, you know, with the reboot, which has certainly been successful [starting] with Casino Royale, I'm thinking of the casting and perhaps the kind of trajectory of certain other supporting characters. So we've had Naomi Harris, a very fine British actress, cast as Moneypenny. And we didn't know she was Moneypenny in Skyfall. We thought she was just Eve, another sort of sidekick. But ever since Skyfall in 2012, that character has really been relegated to desk duty and doesn't have that much to do. So she had a very strong start, but actually hasn't had much of a follow up. I'm thinking also of Jeffrey Wright, the American actor who plays Felix Leiter, again, a black character played by an African-American actor. Felix Leiter from the novels, Bond's longtime ally, good friend, often in scrapes together, has absolutely no discernible effect on any of the plots in the films he appears in. So he appears in Casino Royale, he effectively performs a kind of martial aid symbol when Bond kind of gets booted out of the casino game. Leiter, CIA agent, comes in and gives him the money to buy himself back into the game. On the condition that the CIA get to take in Le Chiffre as though they've done all the work. So again, it's a kind of wry way of saying, "we'll provide the money, but we're not actually going to do the work". Again, in Quantum of Solace, [Leiter's] role is reduced to bureaucracy. So I don't necessarily see there being a great advancement in terms of the representation of African-American characters.

And then finally, I'd say, Judi Dench, Dame Judi Dench, much lauded, well deserved. And again, spoiler for those who have not seen Skyfall, although it's been 13 years so I should hope that at least quite a few listeners have seen it... As I said, it is the most successful of the Bond films financially speaking. It took over a billion dollars. It was that time that coincided with the Diamond Jubilee, the Olympics. Dame Judy's character, Bond's boss, is killed off at the end of that film. And arguably over her tenure, an awful lot of the plots of the film [revolve around her mistakes], I'm thinking of The World is Not Enough, where her mistakes perhaps lead to almost nuclear Armageddon. And again, arguably the plot of Skyfall is entirely her fault in terms of her treatment of Javier Bardem's character as a rogue agent. So in terms of the representation, not just of African-American actors, not just of Black British actors, but in terms of older female actors as well, I don't necessarily see the series as having been as progressive in its representation of, let's say, other demographics as it might necessarily be.

JB: So that's who we're talking about and what we're talking about when we're talking about Bond. But Kathy, I know you've been working with Ian and with Ellie thinking about how do we use Bond in conversations with young people, conversations with families. Why do you think that bond is a good vehicle for these kind of conversations and this kind of education?

KW: So first of all, I think it's an amazing asset within family life to be able to have dialogue about anything to do with all of the themes that have been aforementioned. But I think Bond is someone every single member of one's family will have a view about and some sort of historic relationship with the films themselves. So I think you don't need to sort of begin, you know, start from the beginning with Bond. It's something around the dinner table that you can get stuck into and you have a sort of a pre-existing knowledge of and everything that Ian has said about the of the embodiment of British values, you know, manliness, masculinity, you know, why do we like Bond? Why do we dislike? Is there anything we dislike about him?

It's so easy to have an opening dialogue with your children about [Bond]. Even grandparents will have views about Bond. So, for example, a friend of mine was talking about Bond around the dinner table and the granddad said they loved Sean Connery and the granny said that was her favorite actor as well. And then, you know, the younger child was able to say, but, you know... he's on YouTube talking about hitting women, you know, as a real person. And that obviously brings out and surfaces a lot of contradictions, you know, it initiated a dialogue about the commentary underneath the YouTube video that's still there. Lots of people talking about it, agreeing with Sean Connery in 2024. So there's so much material under that umbrella of Bond for family dialogue.

JB: That's so interesting because it raises the question [and shows how] Bond remains relevant. I remember when chatting to Elly [Hanson] about some of the work that you've been doing... my initial thought was that we're always thinking about how do we ensure PSHE is kind of up to date and relevant. And the natural thing when thinking about how we can teach about relationships or misogyny [is to say] like, OK, well, we should be talking about the latest energy drink, vlogging influencer who's doing the rounds on TikTok. But from the discussion we've had, it sounds like Bond not only retains relevance, but actually, you know, through being able to view Sean Connery on YouTube saying these things [etc. manages to avoid] being disconnected from young people's lives as well.

KW: That's right. I mean, there's so much pre-existing material with Bond. And I think it's, he's fresh in the memory, even for younger generations, because of the Olympics. Everyone remembers the tea with the queen, that scene. And I think, you know, it's the lens through which we can initiate so many conversations about so many topics that are really, really urgent. So in terms of, as Elly referred to earlier, you know, that man box that is born sort of restrained by who we want him to be, what is attractive about him? [Because] when we're speaking to young people, we really have to acknowledge that there's an attraction in many of his qualities and characteristics, but also [to consider] whether his values are reflective of our own, you know, as individuals, as viewers of the film. There's so much to unpick over time.

EH: And I think one of the other reasons why Bond is a useful vehicle for the kinds of conversations that Kathy's outlining there is because actually young people aren't too attached to him. So coming back to your point, Jono, of, you know, the natural thought can be we need to have somebody that's really relevant right now. But actually, Andrew Tate, for example, has been a figure of impact in recent years. [and], if you start conversations about Andrew Tate in a classroom, that's going to open a whole can of worms that's not necessarily helpful and potentially engender quite a lot of defensiveness from some boys who maybe have taken on board some of his messages. So the beauty of Bond is that he's of eternal significance, but young people are not actually that identified with him or wedded to him, which provides some freedom to look at what he's all about and whether they do want to embody some of his qualities or not.

KW: I think the difficulty with a figure like Andrew Tate, whilst a very important figure to talk about in terms of the overt misogyny displayed in his billions of views, is as a parent, if you don't have some knowledge of him and knowledge of the content, you can just end up in a of a battle of words. And I think with Bond, he helpfully allows us to recognise the tension between some of the qualities in a character that are really attractive and that are appealing to us and we like to see on the screen [and those that are not]... But also the contradiction of caring about a character while [at the same time] not really approving of some of his attitudes and views. So, Andrew Tate can be much harder to talk about and to deal with those kind of rationalisations that a young person might put forward... Whereas with Bond, you can empathise with your child that, yeah, you know, I find it disappointing that maybe, you know, some of the qualities that, you know, he exposes aren't really... Should we be clapping in the theatre to those? So I think that it's a nice kind of shared platform that Bond provides... a little bit more easily than some of the more extreme figures I think that are more contemporary even.

EH: And this speaks to the power of fiction doesn't it? That actually taking one step away from all of these real world people... and there's a playfulness and creativity and exploration in fiction. We know that through fiction we can explore the deepest truths in a way that sometimes facts can't get to.

JB: Coming back to this point about parents, families... Bond having been part of people's lives for so many years, and yet looking back, most people having some kind of nagging understanding of the problematic things... In conversation with you [Ian] earlier... It raised questions like how many times has Bond raped someone?

IK: Yeah, it's it's troublingly more than perhaps the casual viewer might think. It's at least five or six times that it's happened. And I was doing some research around this just to check some of the of stats that I think might be useful for this conversation. And there was a wonderful article on unsafe sex in the James Bond films by Lara Zegers and Richard Zegers. And they provided some really interesting stats that I think unfortunately play out in some of the troubling narratives we're addressing here.

Bond has had sex with 58 different women across the films. 22% of those women have, during that sexual intercourse [or] just beforehand, consumed alcohol to minor, moderate, large degrees. No type of contraception is ever mentioned or used. There's never in a sort post-coital scene, any disposal of contraceptive materials. Sexually transmitted diseases don't seem to exist in this world. You'd think someone who is so prolific, someone who does not use protection, someone who perhaps might have, to use the casual term, slept around a bit, that [STDs] might exist to a degree more than they do. But also perhaps maybe more troubling for where we're going to go with this... a total of 28 % of the women that Bond sleeps with don't actually survive to the end of the film. So there is a very clear correlation in these narratives between the role of so-called Bond girls/women as objects of sexual desire, as objects period, and as characters, if we may call them characters, who meet an end prematurely as is often the case, which is quite troubling.

There was another article written by a team of researchers from the University of Otago in New Zealand, and they looked at the degree to which Bond consumes alcohol. And they said, if Bond were a real person, not only does he outdo the average British male in terms of sexual appetite and consumption, but his blood alcohol level would be so high, it would be at a sort of non-functioning level. This is a physical biological impossibility represented and distilled in this character. So we've got a few things there... We've got the issues around sexually transmitted diseases, alcohol consumption [and] the casual disposal and treatment of women that I think will play out a little bit more in our conversation around some of the kind of more problematic elements and how we might use Bond to redress and talk about some of these issues in a healthy and productive way.

JB: I'm just loving this international network of Bond researchers, a sort of shadowy, SPECTRE-like organization with academics cat stroking...

IK: I'm afraid if I tell you any more, you will be subjected to some sort of pool of piranhas or some sort of electrical chairs... I'm not going to say any more about that...

JB: I have my cyanide pill just behind my tongue....

[laughter]

JB: So Kathy... thinking about this incredibly rich material [we've got] to explore so many different issues with children and young people... What's the routine? Where do we start?

KW: I think first of all, recognising the importance, the critical importance of engaging with our children about anything. But all of these contemporary themes, you know, the real engine room for this dialogue is at home and around that dinner table first and foremost. I think that there has to be a diffusion of responsibility always between what's happening in school with PSHE, but also we need alignment between home and school.

And for sort of parents listening, I think it's really important to just start the conversation, to ask great questions, to open up that child's thinking. What do you think about Bond? You know, I was listening to this podcast and they were talking about his different qualities. Do you have a favorite Bond? Literally, just start there and follow that yellow brick road of their thinking. But always with an eye to not end up in a battle of ideas.

But the mission is really to increase their cognitive flexibility around these ideas, to just sprinkle the conversation with, do you think this could be the case? Do you think he really is a good example of the embodiment of British values? I every teenager in the world will have an opinion about that. So I think that our mission is to just bring these questions into this space and model an interest in them.

model and interest in what masculinity, how it's represented. You know, just, just you don't need to be an expert or a clinical psychologist or even a criminologist to have those dialogues. It is caring about these things and caring about how things make us feel. So you might watch, you know, a Bond film together as a family and you might say, do you know what, this was recorded 13 years ago. And for some reason it doesn't feel as comfortable watching this scene. I wonder why that is. I think

And as I was saying earlier, you know, it's the one film maybe out of a few that we would watch together with teenagers. And I think that there's huge, fruitful opportunities within that to, you know, as I said, to have those conversations that are multi-generational and really, really important. love that they're sort of not making this a battle of ideas. They're just working to increase that cognitive flexibility, that sort of opening up ideas, which whether we're round

dinner table or in a PSHE classroom, it's not about sort of, you know, this is right. These are the things you should be thinking. It's about enabling that space. Absolutely. also think there's enormous value when you hear your child critically engaging with it. That's a very precious moment where you can validate, you know, how they're feeling and say, you know, really love, agree. Yeah, I can see that this is an animating conversation for you. I can see this is really interesting to you. I really love hearing your ideas. You've made me think.

So I think that there are ways to have those conversations that will actually, we want these young people to bring these conversations back into the common room, to say, what do you think about James Bond? Just literally stirring the pot and igniting those conversations will be very, very valuable. Ellie, we've heard from Ian about the role of women in Bond films and women as objects, women who do not survive. What do you think?

taking this to the PSHE classroom and thinking about the work you've done around pornography, thinking about objectification, do you think are some of the ways that we might start to explore that sort of in a classroom dynamic? The place that I would begin with that is gender norms actually and returning to this idea of James Bond being a real man, think following on from Cathy's approach, that's just a really interesting starting point.

let's have a discussion about that. Is he a real man? What would we want a real man to do? And Cathy, Ian and I have devised some lesson resources which we're continuing to work on. But our first lesson is called The Real Man Myth or Idea. we look at, within that we have activities where we look at a whole kind of range of human qualities and then we consider

Which of these skills and qualities does Bond have? In this table, which things can he do? Which things can't he do? you know, does he have the courage to jump off a burning building tick? Does he have the courage to open up about his feelings? Hmm, maybe not. you know, just again, in that curious, open way, we're not coming in with set of right answers, but it's just a very different

place to begin with Bond and gets young people thinking then about what do we mean by these words that we might fling around like strength or courage and also authenticity. So then flowing on from that activity, looking at what those three words mean and opening it up beyond Bond to look at examples of say strength, courage and authenticity in the rest of life and hopefully leaving young people with, like Cathy said, more flexibility.

And fundamentally, what I would hope is that young people have a flexibility around gender norms. Certainly not saying that gender identity is inherently harmful or that gender norms are a problem, but it's when they become very rigid and they are kind of, young people are pressured to live up to them. They require this kind of constant performance.

and they become this straight jacket, then we've got an issue. And so really, we just kind of want to query some of the things that these rigid gender norms are saying to young people and saying, actually, you know, is that really strength? Is that really courage? Or are there different ways of being? And I think we can have exactly the same kinds of conversation around femininity, which we often don't focus on, but arguably, notions of femininity can be just as rigid as those around masculinity and equally constraining. you know,

There's so much that you can kind of flow from this starting point to then explore and discuss. I feel that actually exploring notions of femininity, there's rich material in Bond as well. I was going to ask Ian about sort of the concept of women being rescued by Bond. When I think about Bond films, he's always, you know, the gun's ready, he's ready to, you know, jump in and save that girl from a car that's being riddled with bullets or she's the one that ducks down and he's the one.

firing the bullets and I don't know if that's the case or not. Is there a sort of damsel in distress, a concept within Bond that sort of runs through those films or not? In the films I'd say yes to a certain degree, certainly in the 60s and 70s. Although kind of in a cruel irony, the source material, Fleming's novels, it's really not like that at all. So the films have a huge deal of responsibility in

And I suppose crystallizing and can reify into a certain degree our perceptions of the quote unquote Bond girl or Bond woman. I'll give you an example. I think of a character like Honey Rider from the novel Doctor No. She is an adept swimmer. She is a sort of.

effectively, in all but name and without the qualification, kind of natural scientist. She knows the landscape really well. And in fact, in an awful lot of the novels, not just Dr. No, it is the women who have access to a certain kind of context or contextual knowledge or information that Bond doesn't. And often it is the women who affect the plot to a far greater degree than Bond does. That is not carried over into the films where they seem to present and

and perhaps this is more to do with the visual medium of cinema, they seem to present women as objects to be looked at. And the quality of to be looked at-edness is more, I suppose, readily obvious in that medium than it necessarily is on the page or in the literary form. So absolutely, I would say the Bond films, while they seem to lay claim each iteration or each new film to

an actress might say in a press junket, my Bond girl is not the same as any other Bond girl. She's different. And this is something that actresses have been saying or probably have been coached by the kind of press team to say for years. So I think the Bond films have toyed, deliberately toyed with this notion of female progression. The sense that each film, as we move forward, we're moving forward in some sort of teleological trajectory of what woman is, what a strong woman is. And I think we can all agree putting a machine gun

in a woman's hands doesn't necessarily make her a strong woman. In the same way, going back to Ellie's point, that jumping out of a burning building with a machine gun or not doesn't necessarily make Bond strong in the sense of what we might want to value or talk about when it comes to actual strength and what makes a man a real man.

So I've got a question which is a bit tangential, but I'm going to ask it anyway. Which is about this distinction between the books and the films. Do you think that plays into it as well that there is a more deliberate presentation of femininity in this way in films because they are ultimately a different type of cultural product? I do. I don't know if people are familiar with Laura Mulvey and her work on the male gaze and the degree to which this was originally a kind film studies piece, the notion that...

cinema, film, TV is generally filmed for and from the point of view of the heterosexual male gaze. And by gaze I mean G-A-Z-E and not G-A-Y-S-T just for clarification. This notion that the world is presented in a certain way by men for other men and that includes everything from commercials to porn to Bond films.

The very first moment Sean Connery's lays eyes on Ursula Andress, who plays Honey Rider in that film. She's emerging from the swash on the island in the Caribbean. Bond is tucked under a palm tree, so he is in some sort of lurid, dark shade. He is a literal voyeur. This woman does not know she's being looked at. And a sort of now dated Channel 4 countdown.

the channel for you to do these kind countdowns. This was named the number one sexiest moment in all of cinema of all time up to that point. James Bond voyeuristically perving on Honey Rider coming out of the sea. This notion that this woman has not been given agency in this moment, she is something to be looked at. She's singing to herself. It's a moment of intimacy and privacy. And in the novels, in fact, she doesn't wear any swimwear.

She wears a belt with a knife and Fleming describes her first instinct is to cover her pubis, leaving her breasts exposed. So again, I said a moment ago that yes, film is more sort of perhaps voyeuristically medium than maybe literature. But again, in the sort of pre-popular film age Fleming perhaps was writing in.

you get a sense of there being a titillation on the page. is something that is deliberate. And Fleming was very deliberate about this. His writing, he said, is designed for hot-blooded heterosexual males in trains, at airports, this kind of thing, this pulpy nature of it. So absolutely, think film plays into the nature by which women are represented.

And the Bond films, of course, have a great deal of responsibility for the successive iterations of how their so-called quote unquote strong Bond girls are presented, often, unfortunately, in very detrimental ways. So I think through all of this really highlighting the richness of this material, both in terms of the presentation of masculinity and the presentation of femininity, I think there's obviously this real need.

not to simply present this form of masculinity in a way that is just going to cause defensiveness and is not going to do it in a way that's just going to kind of do down men more broadly. So when thinking about that, how best way to present Bond and also a question of sort of is Bond redeemable? know, could Bond be emancipated from the trauma of his experiences?

I think in watching the last film, there was a of a palpable relief that he had sort of found that paternal side to himself that sort of naturally brought out that kind of the vulnerable side, if you like, or a warmer side that everybody in the cinema welcomed. And I think it opened up that dialogue. What have we been missing? this character's finally been able to let his hair down a little bit and be who he wants to be. And that child was sort of fatherhood.

was the of the redemption. That was what it felt like as a viewer. And I think I remember everybody sighing in the cinema, that there was some kind of relief for everyone, that he didn't have to keep up the stiff upper lip, that this child had brought something out in him, that he'd find this connection that felt good but shocking even to himself. That was my impression of it. And I think that last film allows us to remind our...

boys, know, my children, I've got two teenage boys, that sort of emotional redemption or vulnerability is an exciting space to be in. And it offers the opportunity for connection and relationship. Whereas before he seemed quite someone who just as Ian referred to earlier, was just moving through relationships, that there is opportunity through vulnerability to find the courage. He needed to find courage at the end, didn't he, I think.

and to be able to ignite this new amazing relationship that had so much potential wrapped into it, I think one of the shameful things perhaps about the film that Cathy's referring to, No Time to Die Where Bond Does Die, at the end, it's just as he reaches this moment of apotheosis, the realisation that there's more to life than himself, that he now has fathered a child, he is in love with that child's mother, Lea Seduz, the first.

actress to have really had a major role across more than one film because more often than not in the Bond films we reach the closing credits and we never see that sexual partner at Bond, sexual partner ever again. I think it is a shame that actually clearly even in the worldview of the film, in the ideology of the film, there doesn't seem to be a way to reconcile Bond's emotional maturity or path to emotional maturity with Bond's lifestyle itself. I.E. the only way in which

the film can end is with Bond's death. Now on the one hand we could say that's him, he's fulfilled his life purpose, he's realized actually there's more to it than you know bedding women and shooting bad guys. He's left something on this earth beyond himself. However, we don't see that emotional work being done and I wonder if, to link back to what we're talking about,

Emotional maturity, taking the steps, the effort to address, maybe redress some issues around problematic masculinities. That's hard work. We don't see that modelled at the end of that film. There are moments that we can pick out from the Bond films. mean, the classic example, Ellie and Cathy and I always talk about as Inspector, where Monica Bellucci's character is crying, as Bond is kissing her. We want our young men and our young women

to be emotionally cognizant of what's in front of them. If you are engaging with your partner romantically and you see that they're crying, do you like Bond keep going in your pursuit of romantic conquest? Or do you stop and engage and ask the questions? So to a certain degree, I agree with Cati that this does show a kind of emotional apotheosis in Bond. But to another degree, I don't think...

And I think this is more about the confines of the film and the genre itself of those films. We are not treated to seeing how that reaches its full potential. Yes. And I think that that works beautifully in conversations with young people, doesn't it? Because in a way we're saying, know, Bond gets so far. So how can you go beyond Bond? In a way, more than Bond. How can you be more than who Bond is? How can you develop?

that skill set where you can connect with another human, where you can take responsibility and have commitments. And as you were saying, Jono, it's not that we are judging all of what bond is or epitomises. We just, it's not either or. want young people, my vision, my ambition is that boys and girls, all genders have a freedom around their identity.

You know, masculine or feminine or whatever it is doesn't close off parts of themselves, doesn't close off skills. So be the person that has the courage to jump out of a burning building, but also be the person that has the courage to ask your friend how they're feeling or kind of deal with those difficult emotions that they're holding themselves or whatever it may be. So don't allow these narratives about gender or

else to constrain to be a set of straight jackets which are going to stop you from being who you want to be. Exactly and similarly with women you know yes be into your appearance and makeup and beauty but that's not all of who you are and that's not where your core self-worth lies. It's been incredibly rich and nuanced conversation about bond and it's not about doing bond down it's about recognizing you know we have this extraordinary

extraordinary and unique kind of cultural product through which we can explore a whole range of different things. I know, mean, Ian, you've talked about some of the responses you've had from people when you've talked about Bond, very passionate responses from the sounds of I have. There is an awful lot of people's emotional investment. Their identity is invested in the notion of Bond as a character.

purely I imagine because of the longevity of that character and that genre. It's been around for the best part of, well, 70 years, right? And I'm often asked to comment about sort of matters relating to Bond in different sort of print digital media. And I will often receive a bit of spam for certain people who don't like what I've said or who think that by questioning maybe some of the things that we've been questioning here today about Bond, that I am in some ways

disloyal or that I am disloyal to my gender, my sex, that I'm disloyal to this sort of icon of masculinity, perhaps this icon of Britishness. I'm not British. So there's this really interesting challenge. And I've received some fantastically worded hate mail over the years, which I won't read out here for fear of offending. I'm presuming this person is listening. They probably have no idea. But people do really vehemently object.

to challenging Bond, and I suppose it's just to re-emphasize the point that you made. Yes, we can challenge, softly or otherwise, the ideologies of certain favored or long-held or dear icons of our culture. It doesn't necessarily mean we have to revert to hating them. I I would say I'm a big Bond fan, as much as I think there is a lot of material there to mine.

for discussion and for us to talk about and engage with, it doesn't affect the fact that I will go and line up and see the next film. But I do think, and this is sort of my sort of larger remit in what I do at work, it's about challenging those kind of cultural narratives we have around us. Yes, it's fine to enjoy something, but are there particular political, ideological, sociological reasons why perhaps we enjoy them? Have we challenged those enough? And I think

This is what we're getting at with this project. The question of masculinity, femininity have too long been left uncommented upon. And I suppose what we're doing here is a sort of small part to kind of contribute to questioning those and not just assuming a kind of an essential value when it comes to either quote unquote men or quote unquote women, that these things need to be and should be challenged in a productive way.

a wonderful place to wrap up. But before we do, think just Ellie, if people to take one or two things from this conversation, something perhaps they could take back into their homes, into their classroom, what would you want people to say? I think there's a broad point about fiction, that through fiction we can explore truths in a way that facts can be tricky to get to. you know, linking with what Cathy was saying earlier, I want to just empower listeners to just think about

the fiction that they've enjoyed or not enjoyed and who are the characters in those stories and how might they provide jumping off points for conversations and discussions and debates about gender, emotion. Fundamentally, what does it mean to be human and what do we want it to mean? I think, again, parents don't need to wait for

even PSHE lessons, anything they see on the news. The other day there was a debate about who Juliet could be in Romeo and Juliet. I mean, it's endless. So I think that using everyday moments from the news, things you're reading about, asking your child their opinion around that dinner table, there's quite a lot of evidence that those meal time conversations are not just brilliant for children's mental health, but they're brilliant for developing their thinking and their oracy. It's all good.

And all we're doing today is sort of reminding everyone of the importance of family talk, but particularly on some of these bigger themes that we can actually approach them in ways that feel okay as parents and maybe non-experts, if you like. Thank you. Well, I think for all of the nuance and thought that's gone into this conversation, there is obviously actually only one question that anyone really cares about. And I'm going to come to you for that. Who is the next Bond going to be?

It's an exclusive reveal, Jono. I can in fact tell you and your listeners. It's me. I'm the next James Bond. Is that the first Irish James Bond? No, Pierce Brosnan. Good navin man, Cathy. Cut that out. So there's a lot of speculation around this. lot of names have been mentioned. Richard Madden. I think his profile raised quite a bit after Bodyguard, the BBC series Bodyguard where he played Keely Hall's Bodyguard. James Norton.

I think as well, he's done a lot of period drama and if you look back at the history of someone like Timothy Dalton, Pierce Brosnan, there seems to be a kind of a heritage of in their pre-bond days, a new Bond actor would usually have done quite a bit of period drama and obviously need to look good in a suit, that kind of thing. For my money, it's on Jamie Bell, who listeners might remember from Billy Elliot. He is about the right age that Daniel Craig was when he took on the mantle.

He's recently worked with Barbara Broccoli who produces the Bond films on Film Stars Don't Die in Liverpool with Annette Bening. And he strikes me as someone who has the reasonably low-ish enough profile that the Bond role usually drives into the stratosphere, but is also a really good actor. A lot of people say, what about so-and-so? What about so-and-so? And my instinct is always, mean, Henry Cavill looks good in a suit, but...

I don't think he's a great actor, sorry Henry. And he's already been claimed by Superman and whatnot. there's this sense as well that actually, while Roger Moore in the 70s and the 80s can sort of lift the eyebrow and do very little, know, Daniel Craig has brought a level of acting chops to this that I don't think any of the other actors, in my humble opinion, can, you know, lay a torch to. So I think the next...

person to take on Bond is going to have to be a really good actor as well. Because I think they have raised the game in terms of what the Bond narratives are and can be. Fantastic. Well, you heard it here first. Jamie Bell. Although I have to say listeners will have missed an excellent eyebrow raise from Ian. So I wouldn't rule yourself out of the running just yet. Thank you. Well, thank you so much for what has been a fabulous conversation and we will have to wait and see.

whether Ian is right. But in the meantime, thank you, Cathy. Thank you, Ian. Thank you, Ellie. Look out for resources which will be coming on using James Bond in the classroom, using James Bond in conversations. And we will see you next time. Thank you.

Mario Is The Question is a podcast from Fully Human and the PSHE Association presented by me, Jono Bagley, with music and sound editing by Nathaniel Perne and production support from Sam Harvey.

you